"The Lady, or the Tiger?" Short Story Unit Plan for Grades 7–10
← All articles

"The Lady, or the Tiger?" Short Story Unit Plan for Grades 7–10

Andy Navarro · Short Stories & Literature · · 3 min read

A Lady or the Tiger unit plan: justice debate hook, close reading, characterization, the ambiguous ending, one-pagers, SCR, ECR and a creative ending.


Frank R. Stockton's "The Lady, or the Tiger?" (1882) is the original cliffhanger. A young man must open one of two doors. Behind one is a tiger, and behind the other is a lady he'll have to marry. The princess who loves him knows which is which. Stockton never tells us what happens, and students will argue about it for days. Here's a Lady or the Tiger short story unit plan for grades 7–10.

For more lesson ideas, see the Lady or the Tiger lesson plan post.

Day 1: Hook with justice

Ask students: What makes a justice system fair? Give them a few scenarios and let them decide. Then describe the king's system (guilt or innocence decided by chance) without naming the story. Students are already outraged before they read it.

Day 2: Read closely

Stockton's vocabulary is old-fashioned, so read it aloud and stop to translate tricky passages. Words like semi-barbaric, florid and fervent are worth a quick pause. Students track what we learn about the king, the princess and the young man.

Day 3: Characterization

Students pick the king, the princess or the young man and gather traits with evidence. They turn it into a one-pager: the character in the center, traits around it, evidence with paragraph numbers next to each trait. Hang them up for a gallery walk.

Day 4: The ending

This is the big day. Hold a debate: Did the princess choose the lady or the tiger? Students must use evidence about her character, especially her jealousy and her "semi-barbaric" nature. Then step back and ask why Stockton left it open. What does an ambiguous ending do to a reader?

Day 5: Short constructed responses

Students write 150 to 200 word responses with text evidence. Good prompts:

  • What does the king's justice system reveal about him?
  • Describe the princess's internal conflict.
  • Is the young man's fate decided by choice or by chance?
  • Why does the ambiguous ending work?

Days 6–7: Choose the big writing task

  • Correspondence ECR: write a letter to the king about his justice system and suggest a fairer one.
  • Argumentative ECR: is the king's system ethical? Use the text and real-world examples.
  • Informational ECR: explain the psychology of the ambiguous ending.
  • Creative writing: write the ending from the princess's, the young man's or the king's point of view, matching Stockton's tone.

Day 8 (optional): Character presentations

For older or advanced students, assign a 15 to 20 slide character analysis presentation covering the character's role, motivations, conflicts and a psychological reading.

Questions teachers ask

What is the answer to The Lady, or the Tiger?

There isn't one. Stockton deliberately left the ending open. Readers have to decide based on what they know about the princess.

What grade reads The Lady, or the Tiger?

It's usually taught in grades 7 through 10.

What is the conflict in The Lady, or the Tiger?

The main conflict is internal. The princess must choose between letting the man she loves die or watching him marry someone else.

What is the theme?

Common themes include the power of jealousy, the cost of love, and the unfairness of leaving justice to chance.

Everything in this plan is below: the one-pager, SCR prompts, ECR prompts in three modes, the alternative ending task and the character presentation project.

Save this for laterPin it

Resources from this post

Find your next lesson

Lessons written by a working teacher. Buy one once and it's yours to keep.

Browse the shop
Andy Navarro
About the author

Andy Navarro teaches English II and dual-credit ENGL 1301 at a Texas public high school and leads an early-college program for first-generation and bilingual students. He holds an M.A. in Rhetoric and Composition and is ESL certified. Everything on LootDrop ran in his own classroom first.

More about Andy →

Comments

Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.

    Loading comments...