"The Gift of the Magi" Short Story Unit Plan: 7 Days for Grades 6–8
← All articles

"The Gift of the Magi" Short Story Unit Plan: 7 Days for Grades 6–8

Andy Navarro · Short Stories & Literature · · 5 min read · Updated

A 7-day Gift of the Magi unit plan for middle school: background, vocabulary, figurative language, characterization, irony, theme and a twist-ending task.


O. Henry's "The Gift of the Magi" is the perfect December short story for middle school. It's short, it's public domain, and the twist ending lands even with students who think they've seen every plot trick. Here's a seven-day Gift of the Magi short story unit plan that covers vocabulary, figurative language, characterization, irony, allusion and theme, and ends with students writing their own twist.

For more lesson ideas on this story, see the Gift of the Magi lesson plan post.

Day 1: Background and money then vs. now

Students need two things before they read: when the story happened and what money meant. The story was published in 1905. Della has $1.87, and Jim earns $20 a week. Show what those amounts would be worth today, and students suddenly understand why selling her hair is such a big decision. Finish with an anticipation guide on statements like "The best gifts cost the most money."

Day 2: Read the story

Read it together and stop at a few checkpoints: Della counting her money, Della selling her hair, and Jim coming home. O. Henry's vocabulary is the biggest barrier for 6th through 8th graders, so this is the day to use leveled versions. A modified version in clear modern language and an annotated version with meanings beside the text let every student follow the same discussion. Keep the paragraph numbers the same in every version.

Day 3: Vocabulary and figurative language

Pull 12 to 16 words students actually need (like imputation, parsimony and chaste) and practice them with context clues. Then hunt for figurative language. O. Henry is full of similes, hyperbole and personification, like Della's hair "rippling and shining like a cascade of brown waters."

Day 4: Characters, setting and the narrator

  • Characterization: use STEAL (speech, thoughts, effect on others, actions, looks) to build a chart for Della and Jim.
  • Setting and mood: the shabby flat and the gray backyard tell you everything about their finances.
  • The narrator: O. Henry's narrator talks straight to the reader. Have students find those moments and discuss why he does it.

Day 5: Plot, irony and allusion

Students sort plot cards and build a plot staircase. Then teach the twist as situational irony: each gift is useless because of the other person's sacrifice. Wrap up with the allusions: the Queen of Sheba, King Solomon and the Magi themselves, and why O. Henry calls Jim and Della the wisest of all.

Day 6: Theme and seminar

Students write theme statements on gift tags, using theme samples and non-examples so they don't just write a topic ("love"). A strong theme sounds like "True love means giving up something you value for someone else." Hold a short Socratic seminar on whether the gifts were wasted.

Day 7: Assess

Give a quiz or a 20-question STAAR-style unit test with two short constructed responses. Strong SCR prompts:

  • How does O. Henry use irony to develop the theme?
  • What do Della's actions reveal about her character?

Writing extension: write your own twist

End with a creative writing task. Students write their own O. Henry-style story with a twist ending, using a planner and a rubric. It's a great way to check whether they understand irony, because they have to build it themselves.

Stretch it to three weeks

If you have the time before break, three additions make the story stick. First, pair it with another O. Henry twist. "After Twenty Years" is short, public domain and ends with a surprise that works the opposite way: instead of two people sacrificing for love, a friend chooses duty over friendship. Reading both lets students ask the question STAAR loves: how do two authors (or here, one author twice) build the same effect? Have students fill a simple chart for each story: what we expect, what happens, the clue we missed and what the twist reveals.

Second, add a review day that moves. An escape room works well because every lock can be a skill from the unit: context clues, figurative language, plot order, the story's own numbers ($1.87, $20, $21) and theme. Third, finish with a project instead of (or alongside) a test. A one-pager or a bloom ball asks students to choose quotations, explain symbols and state the theme, and they double as December decor.

A simple order: week 1 is the core unit through irony, week 2 is allusion, symbols, the seminar and the paired passages, and week 3 is the escape room, project days and the final exam.

Make it a center rotation

If your class runs on stations, most of these activities work as learning centers. Vocabulary, figurative language, plot sorting, irony and allusion, and theme tags each make a 15 to 20 minute station.

Questions teachers ask

What grade level is The Gift of the Magi?

It's usually taught in grades 6 to 8. The plot is simple, but the vocabulary is hard, so leveled versions of the text help a lot.

What is the irony in The Gift of the Magi?

Situational irony. Della sells her hair to buy Jim a watch chain, and Jim sells his watch to buy Della combs for her hair. Each gift becomes useless.

Why is it called The Gift of the Magi?

The Magi were the wise men who brought gifts to the baby Jesus. O. Henry says Della and Jim, who gave up their greatest treasures for each other, were the wisest givers of all.

Is The Gift of the Magi in the public domain?

Yes. It was published in 1905, so the full text can be printed and shared freely.

The Gift of the Magi unit below includes the complete story in five versions, daily lesson plans, all the activities in this plan as worksheets, craftivities or centers, a unit test, the Gift Swap writing task and a 30-slide deck.

Want the three-week version ready to go? The Gift of the Magi Complete Bundle has the unit plus seven add-ons, each also sold on its own: the One Dollar and Eighty-Seven Cents escape room, Twist Endings paired passages with After Twenty Years, Wise Fools Christmas activities, the Unwrapped flip book, the Gift Ball bloom ball, the One Page, One Gift one-pager and the Final Wrap final exam.

Save this for laterPin it

Resources from this post

Irony & Its Types

A short slide lesson defining irony and its three types, with a warm-up and examples.

Find your next lesson

Lessons written by a working teacher. Buy one once and it's yours to keep.

Browse the shop
Andy Navarro
About the author

Andy Navarro teaches English II and dual-credit ENGL 1301 at a Texas public high school and leads an early-college program for first-generation and bilingual students. He holds an M.A. in Rhetoric and Composition and is ESL certified. Everything on LootDrop ran in his own classroom first.

More about Andy →

Comments

Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.

    Loading comments...