How to Teach Ethos, Pathos and Logos with Ads: A Two-Week Plan (Grades 6–10)
How to teach ethos, pathos and logos with advertisements: a two-week sequence from spotting the appeals to analyzing, checking the numbers and making an ad, plus the mistakes students make most.
Ethos, pathos and logos are easy to define and surprisingly hard to spot. Students can recite "credibility, emotion, logic" on Monday and still call every ad with a smiling person in it pathos on Tuesday. The fix is practice with texts that are short, visual and built on purpose to persuade. That's exactly what an ad is.
Ads work for every reader in the room. A struggling reader can analyze a headline and a photo. A strong reader can explain why an ad borrows a second appeal to support the first. Here's the sequence I use in grades 6–10, and the mistakes worth watching for.
Start with one question per appeal
Definitions don't help much when a student is staring at an ad. Questions do. Give students three to ask of anything persuasive:
- Who is talking? If the ad leans on an expert or someone trusted (a dentist, a chef, a mountain guide), think ethos.
- How does it make me feel? If the ad is built to stir a feeling (a lonely shelter dog, a grandmother's smile), think pathos.
- Where are the numbers? If the ad proves its point with prices, measurements or comparisons, think logos.
Model it with three ads, one for each appeal, before students try any on their own.
Week 1: spot it, then analyze it
Spot the appeals with a question trail. Post ads around the room. At each one, students decide ethos, pathos or logos, and each answer sends them to a different ad. Right answers carry them around the whole loop; a wrong answer eventually drops them on an ad they've already visited, which tells them to go back and check. It's fast feedback, and it gets the whole class moving. Follow it with a short constructed response: name the appeal, give evidence from the ad, explain it. That's the same answer-evidence-explanation structure students need for STAAR SCRs.
Then analyze with a gallery walk. Spotting an appeal is step one. Rhetorical analysis asks more: Who is the audience? What does the ad want? What's the claim in one sentence? Which technique creates the appeal, and does it work? Eight stations, four or five minutes each, is enough time for real discussion without stalling.
Week 2: question it, then make it
Check the numbers. Students tend to trust any ad with numbers in it, because numbers feel like facts. Give them logos ads where the math is correct, have them check it, and then ask what the ad leaves out. A pass that saves $5 over ten rides is only a deal if you ride ten times. That moment, when a student realizes correct math can still leave out the important part, is the heart of media literacy.
Make an ad. End by putting students on the other side. They invent a product, choose an audience, pick one appeal and design a one-page ad where every part (headline, image, proof line, brand) supports that appeal. On pitch day, classmates guess the appeal before reading the plan. If they guess wrong, the ad needs work, and the creator learns more from that than from any quiz.
Mistakes students make (and what to say)
- "There's a person in it, so it's ethos." A person only builds ethos when the ad points to their expertise or trustworthiness. A smiling child is usually pathos. Ask: does the ad tell you why to trust this person?
- "It makes me want to buy it, so it's pathos." Every ad is trying to make you want something. Ask what the ad uses to get there: a feeling, a trusted voice or proof.
- "It has words, so it's logos." Logos needs reasoning or evidence: numbers, comparisons, facts. A slogan isn't logic.
- Only naming one appeal. Most ads lean on one appeal and borrow from another. A vet holding a bag of dog food is ethos, and the happy golden retriever beside her adds pathos. Reward students who notice both and can say which is stronger.
Use invented brands
Real ads work, but they come with baggage: students argue about the brand instead of the rhetoric, and some ads aren't classroom-appropriate. Invented brands keep the focus on technique, and students can critique them freely. They also make a great model for the final project, where students invent their own.
Questions teachers ask
What grade should learn ethos, pathos and logos?
Most standards introduce persuasive techniques in middle school and expect rhetorical analysis in high school. Ads work across grades 6–10; what changes is how much you ask students to write.
How long does it take to teach the rhetorical appeals?
A focused unit takes about two weeks: a few days to spot the appeals, a few to analyze and evaluate, and a few for students to create. You can also run a single trail or gallery walk as a one- or two-day review.
How do the appeals connect to STAAR?
Persuasive texts and author's purpose show up in reading passages, and short constructed responses ask students to answer, cite evidence and explain. Ad-based SCRs give students that practice with texts they can read in seconds.
If you want it ready to go, Ad Lab is my two-week ethos, pathos and logos unit, built on 26 original classroom ads and organized the same way: The Pitch Trail (a two-trail question trail with four SCRs), Ad Autopsy (an eight-station gallery walk), Fine Print (checking the numbers in logos ads) and Pitch Perfect (a create-your-own-ad project). Each lesson is also sold on its own, and all of them are on the ethos, pathos and logos collection.


Comments
Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.
Loading comments...