"Charles" by Shirley Jackson Lesson Plan: Foreshadowing, Characterization and Theme for Middle School
A "Charles" by Shirley Jackson lesson plan for grades 6–8: a foreshadowing clue hunt, a plot that ends at its climax, indirect characterization, theme across texts, discussion questions and a two-week plan.
Shirley Jackson's "Charles" is the story I use when I want a whole class to gasp at the same time. Laurie starts kindergarten and comes home every day with stories about a classmate named Charles, who is always in trouble. His parents can't wait to meet Charles's mother. Then they go to the parent-teacher meeting.
If your students already know "The Lottery," this is Jackson at her funniest, and it teaches foreshadowing better than almost anything else. Here is how I teach it in grades 6 through 8.
Before reading
Ask: "Have you ever told a story about 'a friend' that was really about you?" Let students laugh about it, and don't explain why you're asking. They'll figure it out.
Then give one job while reading: track every report Laurie brings home about Charles, and how Laurie acts at home on the same day.
Day 1–2: read and track the clues
Read the story aloud (it takes about 15 minutes). Pause at each report. Students fill in a two-column chart: what Laurie says Charles did, and what Laurie does at home. By the third or fourth day of the story, some students start to suspect. Don't confirm anything.
After the ending, go back and turn the chart into a foreshadowing clue hunt: which clues were there all along? Which ones did you notice the first time? Rereading with the ending in mind is the best lesson in foreshadowing there is.
Day 3: a plot that ends at its climax
Most stories have a falling action and resolution. "Charles" stops at the moment of the reveal. Map the plot and ask: why would Jackson end it right there? What happens next, and why don't we need to see it?
Day 4–5: indirect characterization
Jackson never tells us what Laurie or his parents are like. She shows us. Use the STEAL method (speech, thoughts, effect on others, actions, looks) to build a character profile of Laurie and then of his mother. The mother is the more interesting one: how does she not see what's happening?
Week 2: theme across texts
The ending lets students talk about a real idea: people often can't see the truth about someone they love, or about themselves. Pair "Charles" with another short text on the same theme, then have students:
- Find a connection between the two texts.
- Write a common theme statement that fits both.
- Write a short comparison essay with evidence from each.
Discussion questions
- When did you first suspect who Charles really was? What clue gave it away?
- Why do you think Laurie invents Charles?
- Why don't Laurie's parents figure it out? What does that say about them?
- Is "Charles" a funny story, a sad story or both?
- Who is responsible when a kid misbehaves at school: the kid, the parents or the school?
Getting the text
"Charles" is still under copyright, so use your anthology or a licensed copy. It appears in many middle school literature textbooks.
Questions teachers ask
What grade level is "Charles" by Shirley Jackson?
It's usually taught in grades 6 and 7, and works for 8th grade as a short foreshadowing lesson.
What is the twist in "Charles"?
At the parent-teacher meeting, Laurie's mother learns there is no Charles in kindergarten. The stories were about Laurie himself.
What is the theme of "Charles"?
Common theme statements focus on how people, especially parents, can be blind to the truth about the people closest to them.
Want the full unit? Blame It on Charles is a two-week unit with a foreshadowing clue hunt, plot and inference pages, two indirect characterization organizers, two original paired stories for theme analysis across texts, an essay prompt and rubric, a skills test and a modified test. For older students, see The Lottery Lesson Plan and Is "The Lottery" Appropriate for Middle School?


Comments
Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.
Loading comments...