Is "The Lottery" Appropriate for Middle School? What to Know Before You Teach It
← All articles

Is "The Lottery" Appropriate for Middle School? What to Know Before You Teach It

Andy Navarro · Short Stories & Literature · · 4 min read

Is "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson appropriate for middle school? What happens in the story, which grades it fits, and how to teach it to 7th and 8th graders.


Short answer: yes, for most 7th and 8th grade classes, with some preparation. Shirley Jackson's "The Lottery" is one of the most commonly taught short stories in American schools, and it shows up in middle school and high school textbooks alike. But it ends with a death, and it is fair to think about your students before you hand it out.

Here is what is in the story, which grades it fits best, and how to teach it so the ending leads to thinking instead of just shock.

What actually happens in the story

A small village gathers on a sunny June morning for its yearly lottery. The mood is ordinary: children play, neighbors chat, a man named Mr. Summers runs the drawing. One family is chosen, then one person from that family, Tessie Hutchinson. In the final lines the villagers, including her own family, pick up stones and close in on her.

That is the whole concern. There is no profanity and no sexual content. The violence comes in the last few sentences and is not described in detail; the story ends as the stoning begins. What disturbs readers is not gore. It is how calm and normal everyone is.

Which grades it fits

  • 6th grade: possible with a strong class, but most of the meaning is in the irony and symbolism, and many 6th graders are left with only the shock. I would wait.
  • 7th and 8th grade: a good fit. Students this age have read darker novels, they care a lot about fairness, and they are ready for the real questions about tradition and going along with a group.
  • 9th and 10th grade: the most common placement. Here you can go further into symbolism, tone and the story's place in history.

The reading level itself is not the obstacle. The sentences are plain and the vocabulary is manageable. The challenge is the theme.

What makes it worth teaching

  • Foreshadowing. The piles of stones, the nervous jokes and the men standing apart are all there on page one. Students love going back to find what they missed.
  • Irony. A lottery is supposed to be something you want to win. The pleasant setting works against what happens.
  • Symbolism. The shabby black box nobody wants to replace is one of the clearest symbols in any short story.
  • Theme. Why do people keep doing something harmful because it has always been done? Middle schoolers have a lot to say about that.

How to teach it to middle schoolers

  • Start with tradition, not the story. Before reading, have students talk about traditions they follow without knowing why, and whether it is ever right to break one. This gives them a frame for the ending.
  • Don't spoil the ending, but don't ambush anyone. You can say, "This story has a dark ending that we are going to talk about," without saying what it is. If you know a student has had a recent loss or trauma, a private word ahead of time is kind.
  • Read it in one sitting. It takes about twenty minutes aloud. Stopping overnight right before the end does not help anyone.
  • Go straight to a second read. Right after the ending, send students back to find the clues. Turning shock into a search for evidence is what makes the lesson work.
  • Keep the questions on the villagers. Why does nobody stop it? Who could have? What does Old Man Warner represent? This keeps the talk about choices and away from the violence.
  • End with writing. A short constructed response on theme or foreshadowing gives every student a place to put their reaction.

If a parent asks

It helps to have a plain answer ready. The story has been widely taught for decades, the violence is brief and not graphic, and the purpose is to get students thinking about peer pressure and harmful traditions. If your school expects it, send a short note home before you start, and have a different short story ready for any family that opts out. In practice that is rare.

Questions teachers ask

What grade level is "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson?

It is most often taught in grades 7 through 10. The text is easy to read, but the theme and irony suit students from about 7th grade up.

Is "The Lottery" too violent for 7th grade?

For most classes, no. The only violence is in the last lines and it is not described in detail. Preparing students with a discussion of tradition and following the reading with close analysis makes a big difference.

What is the theme of "The Lottery"?

The most common reading is the danger of following tradition without question. Students also write about how ordinary people can take part in cruelty when a group expects it.

How long does it take to teach?

The story takes one class period to read. A full study with pre-reading, a second read, discussion and a written response takes three to five days.

If you want it planned out, my unit for "The Lottery" has a middle school track and a high school track, with slide decks for both, a pre-reading activity and SCR and ECR prompts. You can also read my day-by-day unit plan, or see more stories like it on the short story units page.

Save this for laterPin it

Resources from this post

Find your next lesson

Lessons written by a working teacher. Buy one once and it's yours to keep.

Browse the shop
Andy Navarro
About the author

Andy Navarro teaches English II and dual-credit ENGL 1301 at a Texas public high school and leads an early-college program for first-generation and bilingual students. He holds an M.A. in Rhetoric and Composition and is ESL certified. Everything on LootDrop ran in his own classroom first.

More about Andy →

Comments

Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.

    Loading comments...