Banned Books Week Activities for Middle and High School: A Book Tasting That Lets Students Decide
← All articles

Banned Books Week Activities for Middle and High School: A Book Tasting That Lets Students Decide

Andy Navarro · Short Stories & Literature · · 4 min read

Banned Books Week activities for grades 7–12: a banned books book tasting, banned vs. challenged notes, research, book talks and a who-decides discussion.


Tell a room of teenagers that a book has been removed from shelves somewhere, and suddenly everyone wants to read it. Banned Books Week is one of the easiest weeks of the year to get students excited about reading, and you don't have to pick a side in a debate to teach it well. The goal is to get students reading, thinking and deciding for themselves.

Here are the Banned Books Week activities I use with middle and high school students, built around a book tasting.

When is Banned Books Week?

Banned Books Week is usually held in late September or early October. It's sponsored by the American Library Association and other groups that support the freedom to read. Check the ALA's site (ala.org/bbooks) for this year's dates and for current lists of challenged books. The lists change every year.

Start with two words: challenged vs. banned

Students use "banned" for everything, so start with the difference:

  • A challenge is an attempt to remove or restrict a book because someone objects to it.
  • A book is banned when it is actually removed from a school, classroom or library.

Then walk through how a challenge usually works in a school: a parent or community member files a request, a committee reads the whole book, and the district decides whether it stays, moves to a different age group, or is removed. Students are often surprised that there's a process at all.

Warm up: where do you stand?

Give students a handful of statements and have them agree or disagree, then move to the four corners of the room:

  • Parents should be able to choose what their own children read.
  • One person should be able to remove a book for everyone.
  • A book can be uncomfortable and still be worth reading.
  • Students should help decide what is in their school library.

The first and second statements are the interesting pair. Most students agree with the first and disagree with the second, which opens up a great conversation about the difference between "not for me" and "not for anyone."

The main event: a banned books book tasting

Set tables with banned and challenged books, put a table tent on each one, and give students six to eight minutes per "course." For each book they:

  1. Look at the cover and the back. What do they expect?
  2. Read the first page and copy a line that hooked them (or didn't).
  3. Rate it from one to five stars.
  4. Decide: want to read, maybe later, or not for me.

Ring a bell, rotate, repeat. Six courses fit in one class period. By the end, every student has a short list of books they actually want to read.

Which books? Middle school tables might include The Giver, New Kid, Ghost Boys, The Outsiders, Bridge to Terabithia or A Wrinkle in Time. High school tables might include Fahrenheit 451, The Hate U Give, Speak, Maus, The House on Mango Street or Of Mice and Men. Preview every title for your students and your district, especially at the high school level.

No classroom library? Run it digitally. Most library ebook apps and publishers offer free samples of the first chapter, so students can taste books on a device.

Research: the challenge detective

After the tasting, each student picks one book and researches its real challenge history: where and when it was challenged, who challenged it, the reasons given, and what happened. Point students to reliable sources like the ALA's Office for Intellectual Freedom, PEN America, local news coverage and school board records. This turns into an authentic lesson on evaluating sources, because claims about book bans get repeated online without dates or details.

Book talks

Students pitch one book from the tasting to the class in 60 seconds: a hook, who the book is about, why it was challenged in one sentence, and who should read it. Book talks get more books checked out than anything a teacher can say.

Wrap up: who decides?

End the week with a short argument: who should decide which books are in a school library? Parents, teachers, librarians, students or the school board? Ask for a clear claim, two reasons with evidence, and a fair response to someone who disagrees. Strong students usually land on some version of "everyone has a role," which is a mature place to end up.

A few tips that keep it balanced

  • Keep the focus on reading. The point is the freedom to read and the habit of choosing books, not attacking anyone who has objected to one.
  • Respect families. A quick note home explaining the activity goes a long way, and families can always guide their own child's choices.
  • Offer choice. No student has to read any specific book from the tasting.

Questions teachers ask

What are good Banned Books Week activities for high school?

A banned books book tasting, a research activity on one book's challenge history, student book talks and a short argument about who should decide what students read all work well in grades 9–12.

Can I do Banned Books Week in middle school?

Yes. Choose challenged books that fit your students, like The Giver, New Kid or Bridge to Terabithia, and keep the focus on choosing books and understanding how challenges work.

What's the difference between a banned book and a challenged book?

A challenge is an attempt to remove or restrict a book. A ban is when the book is actually removed.

If you'd like it ready to go, Open Shelf is my banned and challenged books book tasting for grades 7–12. It has middle and high school menus, six-course tasting notes, banned vs. challenged guided notes, a challenge detective research page, a book talk planner, a reflection, table tents and an editable digital menu where every book links to its own page.

Save this for laterPin it

Resources from this post

Open Shelf: Banned + Challenged Books Book Tasting (Grades 7–12)

A book tasting with banned and challenged books for middle and high school. Students learn the difference between a challenged and a banned book, taste books from a 16-title middle school menu or a 20-title high school menu, rate them on a six-course recording sheet, research one book's challenge history and write about who should decide what students read. Includes table tents, a book talk planner, a reading wish list and an editable digital menu where every book links to its own page.

Genre Quest: Reading Personality Quiz + Book Rec Bookmarks (Grades 6–12)

A 12-question reading personality quiz brochure that matches students with one of 8 genres (realistic, fantasy, sci-fi/dystopian, historical, mystery/thriller, horror, adventure/survival, humor), with a score flap, genre results and a to-read list. Includes a reflection sheet, 10 "If you like..." bookmarks with middle school and high school picks (plus nonfiction and novels in verse), two make-your-own bookmarks and teacher notes. Fully editable.

Page One Drop: First Chapter Friday Graphic Organizers, Print + Digital (Grades 4–12)

Eighteen original First Chapter Friday listening organizers for grades 4–12, each with art students color while they listen: a movie ticket, popcorn bucket, group chat, TBR shelf, mood forecast, setting map, mixtape, Hook-o-Meter, question jar, level-complete game screen, newspaper, reader battery and more. Includes a First Chapter Friday version, an any-day version, a digital version with an editable title and a teacher guide.

Find your next lesson

Lessons written by a working teacher. Buy one once and it's yours to keep.

Browse the shop
Andy Navarro
About the author

Andy Navarro teaches English II and dual-credit ENGL 1301 at a Texas public high school and leads an early-college program for first-generation and bilingual students. He holds an M.A. in Rhetoric and Composition and is ESL certified. Everything on LootDrop ran in his own classroom first.

More about Andy →

Comments

Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.

    Loading comments...