"All Summer in a Day" Story vs. Movie: A Compare and Contrast Lesson for Middle School
← All articles

"All Summer in a Day" Story vs. Movie: A Compare and Contrast Lesson for Middle School

Andy Navarro · Short Stories & Literature · · 3 min read

How to teach Ray Bradbury's "All Summer in a Day" with a film comparison for grades 6–8: viewing notes, an element-by-element chart, a Venn diagram, discussion questions and a compare-and-contrast paragraph.


Ray Bradbury's "All Summer in a Day" might be the most discussed short story in middle school, and for good reason. On a rainy planet where the sun comes out for one hour every seven years, a group of children locks away the one classmate who remembers what the sun looks like. Students are angry at the ending, which is exactly the point.

It's also one of the best texts for teaching the standard students rarely practice: comparing a story with a film version (RL.6.7, RL.7.7). Here is how I run it.

Day 1: read the story

Read it aloud or with partners. While reading, students track three things: how Bradbury describes the rain, how the other children treat Margot, and how Margot is different from them.

Stop before the last section and ask students to predict what happens when the sun comes out. Then finish it. Give them a minute to just react before you discuss.

Day 2: discuss the big questions

  • Why do the children treat Margot the way they do?
  • Is William a villain, or just a kid who goes along with the group?
  • What do you think happens after the story ends?
  • Who is responsible: the leader, the followers or the kids who stayed quiet?

Bring it back to their world without making it a lecture: "Where do you see groups turn on one person?" Students usually connect it to online pile-ons on their own.

Day 3: watch the film version

There are short film adaptations of the story, including a well-known television version. Preview any version before showing it in class. Students take viewing notes in a few categories:

  • Characters: who was added, left out or changed?
  • Setting: how does the film show the rain and the sun?
  • Mood: what do the music, lighting and camera do that the words did?
  • Climax and ending: do they match the story?

Day 4: compare element by element

A Venn diagram is a fine start, but an element-by-element chart produces better writing. Make rows for characters, setting, conflict, mood, climax and ending, with one column for the story and one for the film. The last column asks the most important question: why might the filmmaker have made that change?

Day 5: write a compare and contrast paragraph

Students pick the most important difference and write a paragraph with a clear claim, evidence from both versions and an explanation of the effect. A paragraph frame with sentence starters helps:

  • "In both the story and the film, ..."
  • "However, the film ... while the story ..."
  • "This change makes the audience feel ... because ..."

Getting the texts

The story is under copyright, so use your anthology or a licensed copy, and choose a film version your school has access to.

Questions teachers ask

What grade is "All Summer in a Day" for?

It's most often taught in grades 6 and 7, and it works for 8th grade too.

What is the theme of "All Summer in a Day"?

Common themes include the cruelty of a group toward someone who is different, envy, and the courage it takes to stand apart.

How do I teach comparing a story to a movie?

Read the story first, take structured viewing notes on specific elements, compare them in a chart, and always ask why a filmmaker made each change. Then write one focused paragraph.

Want the pages ready to print? One Hour of Sun is a free compare-and-contrast set with viewing notes, a Venn diagram, an element-by-element chart, a paragraph frame, discussion questions and a Google Slides version. For a nonfiction version of the same standard, One Pen, One Voice compares Malala's UN speech in print and on video. More stories are on the literature and short stories page.

Save this for laterPin it

Resources from this post

Find your next lesson

Lessons written by a working teacher. Buy one once and it's yours to keep.

Browse the shop
Andy Navarro
About the author

Andy Navarro teaches English II and dual-credit ENGL 1301 at a Texas public high school and leads an early-college program for first-generation and bilingual students. He holds an M.A. in Rhetoric and Composition and is ESL certified. Everything on LootDrop ran in his own classroom first.

More about Andy →

Comments

Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.

    Loading comments...