The Case Against Montresor: Cask of Amontillado Argument Writing (Grades 8–10): Writing prompts & lessons for grades 8–10
The Case Against Montresor: Cask of Amontillado Argument Writing (Grades 8–10) preview page 1The Case Against Montresor: Cask of Amontillado Argument Writing (Grades 8–10) preview page 2The Case Against Montresor: Cask of Amontillado Argument Writing (Grades 8–10) preview page 3The Case Against Montresor: Cask of Amontillado Argument Writing (Grades 8–10) preview page 4

The Case Against Montresor: Cask of Amontillado Argument Writing (Grades 8–10)

Writing prompts & lessons · Grades 8–10 · PDF + PowerPoint · $2

An argumentative writing prompt: is Montresor a reliable narrator, or is he hiding the truth from "you"? A second prompt asks whether revenge is ever justified. Students plan a claim, two pieces of evidence, reasoning and a counterclaim, then draft and score with the rubric.

Inside: Two prompts: is Montresor reliable? is revenge ever justified? · claim + evidence planner with counterclaim · draft page · 4-level rubric · full story text.

Teacher notes and a printable PDF plus an editable digital version are included. The complete story is printed in every resource (Edgar Allan Poe, 1846, public domain), with paragraph numbers so every answer can cite the text.

Also included in The Cask of Amontillado Ultimate Bundle.

What's included

  • Two prompts: is Montresor reliable? is revenge ever justified?
  • claim + evidence planner with counterclaim
  • draft page
  • 4-level rubric
  • full story text
  • Teacher notes
  • Editable PowerPoint with type-in boxes

How teachers use it

  • "The Cask of Amontillado" by Edgar Allan Poe
  • Short story unit
  • Grades 8–10

Topics: journal, writing, prompts, bell, ringer, literature, reading, ela, slides, powerpoint, presentation, bundle, value, pack, middle, school, high, grade, 8, 9, 10

Good to know

About this resource

Built for grades 8–10 (middle school and high school ELA). Format: PDF + PowerPoint. $2 on its own, or included with All-Access. Ways to use it: "The Cask of Amontillado" by Edgar Allan Poe; short story unit.

What grade level is this for?

Grades 8–10, so it fits middle school and high school ELA classes.

What format is it?

PDF + PowerPoint. You can edit it to fit your class.

How much does it cost?

$2, or free with an All-Access membership.

What's included?

Two prompts: is Montresor reliable? is revenge ever justified?, claim + evidence planner with counterclaim, draft page, 4-level rubric, full story text, Teacher notes, Editable PowerPoint with type-in boxes.

How can I use it in my classroom?

Popular ways to use it: "The Cask of Amontillado" by Edgar Allan Poe; Short story unit; Grades 8–10.