Thanksgiving Paired Passages for Middle School: How to Pair Texts on Gratitude
← All articles

Thanksgiving Paired Passages for Middle School: How to Pair Texts on Gratitude

Andy Navarro · Seasonal & Holiday · · 3 min read

How to teach Thanksgiving paired passages in middle school: pair an informational text with a narrative on gratitude, then use six question types and a short response.


Paired passages are the hardest thing on most state reading tests, and the week before Thanksgiving is a good time to practice them. Students will read two short texts on a topic they care about more willingly than one long one, and you can finish the whole set in a single class period.

Here is how I set up Thanksgiving paired passages for middle school, and how to stretch the same set for high school.

Pair two genres on one idea

The strongest pairs share an idea, not a subject. Two articles about turkeys give students nothing to compare. An informational article about what gratitude does, next to a personal narrative about a family that always sets one extra chair at the table, gives them plenty. One text explains the idea and the other shows it.

Other pairs that work this week:

  • An article on how a tradition starts, with a narrative about a family changing one
  • A short piece on why people give, with a story about a neighbor who does
  • Lincoln's 1863 Thanksgiving Proclamation, with a modern article about the same holiday

Keep each text to one page. Number the paragraphs so students can cite them.

Give each text one annotation job

Skip "annotate the text." Give one specific job per passage.

  • Informational text: underline the sentence that states the main point, and star the paragraph where the author admits a limit.
  • Narrative: circle two details that show how the narrator felt at first, and box the sentence where that feeling changes.

Those marks become the evidence for the questions.

Six question types to write

A balanced set has two questions on the first text, two on the second and two that need both.

  1. Central idea of the informational text
  2. Word meaning in context, using a word with more than one meaning, such as modest
  3. Author's purpose for including one paragraph
  4. Symbol or theme in the narrative
  5. Character change, with the answer choices as quoted sentences
  6. Cross-text connection: which idea from Text 1 is shown in Text 2?

The last one is the paired-passage skill. If students miss it, have them say the idea from the article in their own words first, then look for where the story acts it out.

Finish with a short constructed response

One prompt that needs both texts: "Both texts suggest that gratitude is something people do, not only something they feel. How does each text show this?" Score it 0 to 2. A 2 answers the question with a clear idea and uses evidence from both texts. A 1 uses only one text or vague evidence.

Give students three checks before they turn it in. Did I answer in my first sentence? Did I use both texts? Did I explain how each piece of evidence proves my idea?

For high school

Use the same pair and raise the question. Ask how each author's choice of genre shapes the message, or which text is more persuasive and why. Honors classes can add a third text, such as a short poem, and write a paragraph that synthesizes all three.

Questions teachers ask

What are paired passages?

Two short texts on a shared topic or idea, followed by questions about each text and questions that require both. State reading tests use them to measure comparing and synthesizing.

How do I teach students to compare two texts?

Give each text one annotation job, have students state the shared idea in their own words, and then ask where each text shows it. Finish with a written response that requires evidence from both.

How long should Thanksgiving paired passages be?

About one page each for middle school. Two one-page texts, six questions and a short response fit in a 45-minute period.

Want it ready to print? The Long Table has this exact set: "What Gratitude Does" and "The Extra Chair," six questions with explained answers, a short constructed response with a sample, and six more Thanksgiving ELA activities for grades 6–12.

Save this for laterPin it

Resources from this post

Finding the Theme Anchor Chart

A bold, colorful Finding the Theme anchor chart with a coloring version, student notes and blank pages so students can build their own.

Context Clues Anchor Chart

A bold, colorful Context Clues anchor chart with a coloring version, student notes and blank pages so students can build their own.

Find your next lesson

Lessons written by a working teacher. Buy one once and it's yours to keep.

Browse the shop
Andy Navarro
About the author

Andy Navarro teaches English II and dual-credit ENGL 1301 at a Texas public high school and leads an early-college program for first-generation and bilingual students. He holds an M.A. in Rhetoric and Composition and is ESL certified. Everything on LootDrop ran in his own classroom first.

More about Andy →

Comments

Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.

    Loading comments...