Is "Approaches Grade Level" Passing on STAAR? The Four Performance Levels Explained
← All articles

Is "Approaches Grade Level" Passing on STAAR? The Four Performance Levels Explained

Andy Navarro · STAAR, TSI & Test Prep · · 3 min read

Is Approaches Grade Level passing on STAAR? Yes. Here is what the four STAAR performance levels mean and how to explain a score report to students and parents.


Yes. On STAAR, Approaches Grade Level is passing. It is the lowest of the three passing levels, and the name confuses parents and students every year because "approaches" sounds like "almost."

Here is what each of the four STAAR performance levels means, in language you can use at a parent conference or with a nervous student.

The four performance levels

  • Did Not Meet Grade Level. Not passing. The student did not show enough understanding of the course content and is likely to need significant support next year.
  • Approaches Grade Level. Passing. The student showed some understanding of the content but has gaps, and is likely to succeed next year with targeted support.
  • Meets Grade Level. Passing. The student showed strong understanding and is likely to succeed next year, though some short-term support may still help. This is the level the state treats as being on track.
  • Masters Grade Level. Passing. The student showed mastery of the content and is expected to succeed next year with little or no support.

So three of the four levels are passing. A student who "approaches" has passed the test.

Passing and on track are two different things

This is the part worth explaining carefully. Approaches is the passing standard. Meets is the level that signals a student is on track for the next grade and, later, for college and career readiness. Schools are also rated partly on how many students reach Meets and Masters, which is why teachers and districts talk about "Meets" so much.

A fair way to say it to a family: "She passed. The score also tells us there are a few skills to shore up, and here is what we're doing about it."

What it means for high school end-of-course tests

For the five STAAR end-of-course exams, Algebra I, English I, English II, Biology and U.S. History, Approaches Grade Level is the passing score that counts toward the testing requirement for graduation. Students who don't pass an EOC can retake it, and Texas has other routes for students who are still short after retesting. Your counselor will have the current rules, and they are the right person for a family's specific situation.

What it means in grades 3–8

Promotion decisions in grades 3 through 8 are made locally, and a student who doesn't pass is generally given extra instruction or tutoring. The rules have changed more than once in recent years, so check your district's current policy before answering that question for a parent.

How to read the score report

  • Scale score. The main number. Each performance level has a cut score, and those differ by grade and subject.
  • Performance level. Which of the four levels the scale score falls in.
  • Reporting categories. How the student did on each group of skills. This is the most useful part for planning, because it shows where the gaps are.
  • Progress. How this year's score compares with last year's.

How to talk about it with students

  • Lead with what the level means, not the label. "You passed, and you were close to Meets" is more useful than a word on a page.
  • Point at one or two skills. Reporting categories turn a score into something a student can act on.
  • Set the next level as the goal. A student at Approaches aims for Meets. That is a clear, reachable target.

Questions parents and teachers ask

Is Approaches Grade Level passing on STAAR?

Yes. Approaches Grade Level is the passing standard. Meets and Masters are higher passing levels.

Is Approaches Grade Level bad?

No. It is a passing score. It does mean the student has some gaps and would benefit from targeted support to be fully on track.

What is the difference between Approaches and Meets?

Both pass. Approaches shows partial understanding of grade-level content. Meets shows strong understanding and is the level considered on track for the next grade.

What score do you need to pass STAAR?

It depends on the grade and subject. Each test has its own scale score cut for Approaches, and TEA publishes the tables every year.

Do students have to pass STAAR to graduate?

Students generally need to pass the five end-of-course exams, with retakes and alternative routes available. Ask your school counselor about the current requirements.

If you are planning review, my STAAR review calendar lays out the weeks before the test, and reading, SCR and ECR practice is collected on the STAAR reading and writing prep page.

Performance levels are summarized from the Texas Education Agency. Requirements change, so confirm graduation and promotion rules with TEA or your district.

Save this for laterPin it

Resources from this post

Math Heroes: Free STAAR Math Practice (Grade 4)

Free STAAR-style math practice for grade 4: 15 multiple-choice questions across all four reporting categories plus a no-choices decimal item (a printed grid for paper practice; typed in an equation editor box on the online test), with an answer key and TEKS.

Find your next lesson

Lessons written by a working teacher. Buy one once and it's yours to keep.

Browse the shop
Andy Navarro
About the author

Andy Navarro teaches English II and dual-credit ENGL 1301 at a Texas public high school and leads an early-college program for first-generation and bilingual students. He holds an M.A. in Rhetoric and Composition and is ESL certified. Everything on LootDrop ran in his own classroom first.

More about Andy →

Comments

Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.

    Loading comments...