The Indiana Pi Bill: A Pi Day Civics Lesson for Middle School
← All articles

The Indiana Pi Bill: A Pi Day Civics Lesson for Middle School

Andy Navarro · Seasonal & Holiday · · 4 min read

How to teach the 1897 Indiana Pi Bill as a Pi Day civics lesson: the story, how a bill becomes law, the role of expert evidence and a short written reflection.


In 1897 the Indiana House of Representatives passed, without a single no vote, a bill that would have put a wrong value of pi into state law. It is a true story, students love it, and it is one of the best ways to teach how a bill becomes law. The process stops being a flowchart and becomes a close call.

Here is how to teach the Indiana Pi Bill as a Pi Day civics lesson in one or two class periods.

The story in five beats

  1. The idea. Edward J. Goodwin, an Indiana physician and amateur mathematician, believed he had solved an ancient problem called squaring the circle. Mathematicians had already proved it could not be done.
  2. The offer. He offered Indiana free use of his discovery in its schools if the legislature would recognize it. A representative introduced it as House Bill 246.
  3. The committees. The bill went first to a committee on canals, then to the committee on education, which recommended it.
  4. The vote. In early February 1897 the House passed it with no one voting against. The count usually reported is 67 to 0. The method in the bill works out to a value of pi of about 3.2.
  5. The catch. Clarence Waldo, a mathematics professor from Purdue, happened to be at the statehouse on other business. He explained the problem to senators. On February 12 the Senate postponed the bill indefinitely, and it never became law.

Step 1: tell it as a mystery (10 minutes)

Start with the vote. "Not one member voted no on a bill about the value of pi. Why would they go along?" Take guesses, then read the story. Students should come away with three reasons: nobody in the room could check the math, the bill sounded official, and it appeared to cost the state nothing.

Step 2: trace the bill (15 minutes)

Have students place the events on a bill-to-law flowchart: introduced, sent to committee, reported out, passed by one chamber, sent to the other, stopped. Then ask where a bill can die. In this case it was the second chamber, which is the reason legislatures have two.

This is the content the lesson is for. A bill needs both chambers and the governor. Checks are built in so that one fast vote is not enough.

Step 3: talk about evidence (10 minutes)

  • Who is responsible for checking a claim before a vote?
  • What did the lawmakers need that they did not have?
  • Can a law change a fact? What can a law change?
  • Where do lawmakers get expert advice today?

The last question connects to hearings, testimony and staff. Keep the discussion on process and off current political fights.

Step 4: write (10 minutes)

A short civic reflection: "Explain why the Indiana Pi Bill nearly passed and what finally stopped it. What does the story show about how laws should be made?" Look for two things: the correct sequence of events, and a clear point about evidence or checks.

Add world history

The bill was wrong about something people had been working out for thousands of years. Babylonian and Egyptian scribes used rough values. Archimedes trapped pi between two fractions. Mathematicians in China and India pushed it to more and more digits long before 1897. A map or timeline of who knew what, and when, shows students that knowledge travels and builds, and that the answer was already there for anyone who asked.

Get the facts right

  • It never became law. The House passed it. The Senate set it aside.
  • It did not say "pi equals 3." The bill's method implies a value of about 3.2.
  • The Senate did not vote it down. It postponed the bill indefinitely, which is a quieter way for a bill to die and a useful term to teach.
  • It was not about religion. Students sometimes mix this story up with others.

Outside sources

The Indiana Archives and Records Administration shows the original bill in From the Vault: Pi Bill.

Questions teachers ask

Did Indiana really try to change the value of pi?

In 1897 the Indiana House passed a bill built on a flawed geometry method that implied pi was about 3.2. The Senate postponed it and it never became law.

What does the Indiana Pi Bill teach?

How a bill becomes law, why legislatures have two chambers and committees, and why lawmakers need expert evidence.

What grade level is this lesson for?

Grades 6 through 8 for civics. High school classes can use the story inside a larger study of how mathematics crossed civilizations.

How do I celebrate Pi Day in social studies?

Teach the Indiana Pi Bill for civics, or trace the history of pi across Babylon, Egypt, Greece, China and India on a map and timeline.

Want it ready to print? The Indiana Pi Bill set for grades 6–8 has the reading, a bill-to-law flowchart, a page on how math knowledge traveled and a civic reflection, with an answer key and digital version. High school classes can use the global history of pi DBQ. See every subject in Pi Day activities for grades 3–12.

Save this for laterPin it

Resources from this post

Find your next lesson

Lessons written by a working teacher. Buy one once and it's yours to keep.

Browse the shop
Andy Navarro
About the author

Andy Navarro teaches English II and dual-credit ENGL 1301 at a Texas public high school and leads an early-college program for first-generation and bilingual students. He holds an M.A. in Rhetoric and Composition and is ESL certified. Everything on LootDrop ran in his own classroom first.

More about Andy →

Comments

Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.

    Loading comments...