Discussion Board Icebreakers for Online, Dual Credit and College Classes (That Get Real Replies)
Discussion board icebreakers for online and dual credit college courses: seven prompts that get real replies, how to write reply guidelines, and live online and in-person versions of each.
The first discussion board of the semester usually goes like this: "Hi, my name is Jordan, I am a junior, I like basketball and pizza." Twenty-five posts that look the same, and replies that say "Cool! I like pizza too." Nobody learns anything about anybody, and students learn that discussion boards are busywork.
Icebreakers on a discussion board work when the prompt asks for something specific and a little surprising, and when the reply has a job to do. Here are seven that I use with dual credit and college students.
Seven discussion board icebreakers
1. Two truths and a lie, with a twist
Students post two true facts and one false one about themselves. Classmates reply with their guess and the clue that gave it away. The twist makes replies an inference exercise instead of "lol #2."
2. The object on your desk
Post a photo (or description) of one object within arm's reach and explain what it says about you. People reply with a question about someone else's object.
3. Your best and worst learning experience
One class where you learned the most, one where you learned the least, and why. This one gives you a quick, honest read on how your students learn.
4. A skill you could teach in five minutes
Everyone has one: tying a tie, a card trick, a recipe, a shortcut in a video game. Replies ask one follow-up question.
5. This or that, and defend it
Give three "this or that" choices (early bird or night owl, text or call, book or movie) and ask students to defend one choice in two sentences. Replies push back politely on one of them.
6. The syllabus scavenger hunt
Post five questions whose answers are in your syllabus (late work policy, office hours, how to submit). Students answer and add one question they still have. It is an icebreaker that also saves you 30 emails.
7. A word that describes your writing
For writing courses: one word that describes you as a writer right now, and one word you'd like to describe you by the end of the semester. It is a great first data point for a writing class.
Give replies a job
Most boards fail at the reply, not the post. Give students a short reply guide:
- Use the person's name.
- Connect to something specific in their post.
- Ask a real question you'd like answered.
- Keep it to three to five sentences.
Model it with your own post and reply first. Students copy the tone you set.
Adapt it for live online and in person
- Live online: run "this or that" as a poll, then send pairs to a breakout room to explain their choices. Use the chat for the object-on-your-desk round.
- In person: turn "this or that" into a four-corners activity, and run two truths and a lie at tables.
Questions teachers ask
What are good discussion board icebreakers for college students?
Prompts that ask for something specific: an object on your desk, a skill you could teach in five minutes, your best and worst learning experience, or a this-or-that choice you defend. Pair each with a reply guideline.
How do I get better discussion board replies?
Give replies a job: use the person's name, connect to something specific, ask a real question, and keep it short. Model a reply yourself first.
Do icebreakers work in dual credit courses?
Yes, and they are especially useful there. Dual credit students are often meeting a college instructor for the first time, and a low-stakes first post makes them more willing to participate all semester.
Want 20 ready-to-use icebreakers sorted by format? Common Ground is free and includes seven in-person, six live online and seven discussion board icebreakers, each with steps, timing and a course tie-in, plus a student introduction card, Find Someone Who bingo, the syllabus scavenger hunt, a discussion reply guide, a 42-slide deck and a prompt bank for your LMS. More is on the dual credit English page.


Comments
Questions, tweaks that worked in your room, ideas for other teachers: share them here.
Loading comments...